Care to express an opinion on a current or past historical event?
Need to ask a question from our many visitors?
Just visit our Forum and leave your message.
MONKS AND MONASTICISM
The International History Project
Most Christians, Hindus, Muslims, and members of other religions are ordinary citizens. They raise families, work, play, and are otherwise involved in their societies. In most major religions there are also numerous individuals who devote themselves full-time to the quest for salvation--however that term may be defined. The term used to describe such individuals is monks, and their way of life is called monasticism. Both of these words are derived from a Greek term that means "living alone." The definition was once accurate in referring to early Christian hermits, but today it is misleading because many monks--and their female counterparts, nuns--live in communities. Many are deeply involved in the world around them as teachers, social workers, missionaries, nurses, or in other vocations.
Monks must be distinguished from the clergy. Priests, pastors, and rabbis are full-time professionals who are trained to work in society. They have what is called a religious vocation. But the direction their work takes is quite different from the highly individualized style of life undertaken by monks.
In Christianity the distinction between clergy and monks is not sharply defined. Many monks are clergymen. Roman Catholicism, for example, has two types of clergy--regular and secular. The regular are those who follow a rule (regula in Latin)--they are members of a monastic order. The secular are priests who belong to no order. Many monastic orders have members called brothers who are not priests and who do not perform such priestly functions as conducting mass. They share the life and discipline of the order with ordained monks and serve in such capacities as teaching and farming.
In Hinduism the distinction between monks and priests is more sharply drawn. Only males born into the Brahmin caste are entitled to perform priestly rituals. The privilege is given to all boys born in the highest caste. Monks, by contrast, may perform no priestly functions. Therefore, if a member of the Brahmin caste becomes a monk, he forfeits his right to act as a priest.
Nature of Monasticism
Because the practice of monasticism varies among the world's religions, a precise definition is difficult. Loosely speaking, monasticism refers to individuals who try to practice religious works that are more rigorous and beyond those required by the doctrines of their religion. The works are those that ordinary believers cannot do, for lack of time or inclination.
A more appropriate word for early Christian monasticism, as well as for that practiced by Eastern religions today, is asceticism. It means self-denial, and it is rooted in a negative attitude toward the world. In Christianity the ascetics looked upon the world as a source of temptation and sin. By secluding themselves from it, monks hoped to avoid harmful contacts and to concentrate their energies upon salvation alone.
Monasticism never established itself permanently in Judaism. There were, from the 2nd century BC onward, some groups that opposed the Temple worship at Jerusalem. They also were adamantly against the compromises that Jewish leaders made with the Roman authorities. These groups were separatist, nonconformist, and rebellious. There was little basis in the Hebrew Bible, however, for asceticism. That collection of books depicts the world as essentially good because it is God's creation. Christianity's scriptures take the same position and therefore give little direct support for a life of asceticism.
There have been strong disagreements within Christianity about the merits of monasticism. Some Protestant groups deny its validity altogether. The Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox denominations, however, have maintained strong monastic traditions dating back many centuries. The Anglican Communion also has a number of monastic orders.
Some Eastern religions, especially Buddhism and Jainism, are primarily monastic. The rules for all believers are derived from the monastic rules, but the vows taken by monks are far more numerous and more intensive than those required of lay members.
Personal goals. Some monks separate themselves from the world and its concerns as much as possible. They may join communities, or they may live in solitude in one place or wander around as mendicants (beggars). In either case they pursue highly individual goals. They seek to get rid of all imperfections and to reach a state of spiritual perfection. They feel that isolation from the world and its temptations aids in their quest. In Eastern religions the world and the individual ego must both be subordinated to a search for the real self. The body with its weakness for temptation and the mind clogged by ignorance are also hindrances. The means used to circumvent both the world and the ego is meditation. A Buddhist, Jaina, or Hindu monk attempts to break the cycle of birth, death, and rebirth (called reincarnation) to escape to another kind of existence altogether.
Along with meditation, many monks use mortification as a tool to reach perfection. Mortification literally means "making dead." For monasticism it refers to certain practices that de-emphasize the physical and emphasize the spiritual. Among them are fasting and punishing the body in various painful ways. Sometimes meditation is accompanied by physical exercise. Practices such as these have remained common in Central and East Asia, but they have diminished in Christianity since the end of the Middle Ages.
Social purposes. Not all monks pursue salvation by separation from the world. Some, such as the Franciscans, have combined service to the poor with their individual meditation and study. In the 20th century Mother Teresa founded an order to serve the poverty-stricken millions of India
The Order of the Hospital of St. John of Jerusalem, founded in the 11th century and known as the Knights Hospitalers, was probably the first order to establish genuine medical and hospital services. Members of the Teutonic Knights, founded in 1189, also trained in hospital services. In Tibet the Khamba organized themselves into a military police force for the protection of the higher clergy.
Monasticism has played a vital role in the creation, preservation, and transmission of culture. This was especially true of the Christian orders in the Middle Ages. Often the only literate members of society were the monks. It was they who made and transmitted written copies of the Bible and other ancient works from generation to generation. They organized some of the first libraries. Often they conducted scientific and other research to benefit the surrounding communities. They were expert farmers who were able to pass on the benefits of their expertise to peasants on the large manors.
Types of Monasticism
The two basic kinds of monasticism are eremitic (a hermit life-style) and cenobitic (a communal life-style). Both types have variations, and they are found in most major religions.
Eremitic. The hermits are religious recluses. In the early centuries of Christianity there lived in the Egyptian desert a number of solitaries whose desire was to escape all the evils of the world. They were called eremites, a Greek word meaning "dwellers in the desert." Other religions, notably Jainism and Hinduism, also have had hermit monks. Common to all true hermits is a persistence in living alone and following a strict discipline of meditation and self-mortification.
As the number of Egyptian hermits increased during the 3rd and 4th centuries, they began to gather in small, unregulated groups. These were not communities in the strict sense because each hermit followed his own discipline. There was no communal dining, meditation, or work. Buddhist monks and nuns lived in similar loose associations before permanent communities were established.
Cenobitic. True monastic communities have sets of rules. There are disciplines--including prayer, worship, study, work, and service--that are obligatory for all members. The first community of monks living under one roof and following the same routine was founded in Egypt by the Christian ascetic Pachomius. It was started in about 320 at Tabenna, an island in the Nile River. Pachomius is said to have built nine monasteries for men and two for women.
These monasteries were probably the models for those established by the Greek theologian St. Basil the Great in the 4th century. It was he who set forth the first monastic rule, which became the basis for all later Eastern Orthodox monastic institutions. Basil laid down the principle that the monk must not live for himself alone but must do good for his fellow man. To give his monks the opportunity to put the rule into practice, he established hospitals, hospices, and orphanages near the monasteries. He also provided schools for the education of boys, whether or not they were training to become monks. Basil also taught that work is of greater value than self-mortification and punishment. The best-known monastery in the tradition of Basil is Mount Athos in Greece.
What Basil's rule was for the Eastern church, that of St. Benedict became for Roman Catholicism during the Middle Ages. Benedict of Nursia formulated a rule calling for poverty, chastity, obedience, and stability. His rule also indicated that individual monks were not to own property. It was, rather, to be held by the order and administered by appointed trustees. Benedict exalted work as necessary for the well-being of the individual. He viewed the religious life as essentially social, not personal.
Some orders are semimonastic. Notable among these in Christianity are the Franciscans and Dominicans, both founded early in the 13th century. Members of these orders, while having monasteries as a home base, go out into society as teachers, preachers, and missionaries. Members are called friars, meaning brothers, and they are dependent on offerings from the people for their food and other needs.
A number of Hindu orders also have mendicants who alternate between a communal existence and a public life of teaching or preaching. The Hindu orders are much more loosely organized than either Christian or Buddhist counterparts.
Status of Women
In all monastic traditions, as in most religions generally, women have always occupied a status inferior to men. Roman Catholicism has consistently refused to grant equal status to nuns because they cannot be ordained as priests. Buddha was originally reluctant to allow women into his order. He eventually relented after some of his disciples had succeeded in establishing nunneries.
In the early days of Christianity, women who vowed to give their lives to service to God lived in their homes. Later they lived in communal houses called parthenones, from the Greek word for "virgin." The implication, of course, was that such women would never marry. The word nun is derived from this Greek term by way of the French nonne. During the Middle Ages there were many communities of nuns throughout Europe. Their organizations were, with few exceptions, similar to those of monks.
Monasticism among Christians originated around the 4th century in Egypt and the Middle East. It had come into existence much earlier in the older religions of India, and from there it spread to Southeast Asia, China, Tibet, and Japan.
Hinduism. Monasticism in India owes its origins to Buddhism. Although Buddhism did not survive as a religion in India, it left behind the tradition of the monastic order, or sangha, which was readily absorbed by Hinduism.
The most influential founder of Hindu monasticism was Sankara, a philosopher and theologian in the 8th century. The main currents of modern Indian thought are derived from his doctrines. His order, Dasanami, set the monastic standards for all of Hindu India. It is the strictest of the orders and accepts as members only Brahmins, the highest Indian caste. Monks in this tradition have one chief obligation--meditation. All other tasks such as group incantation of liturgy, teaching, or participation in monastic assemblies are secondary to meditation. The monk has no social obligations, though he may initiate others into the secrets of meditation.
There are about 90 monastic Hindu orders. Not all are as inflexible in their standards for membership or in their rules as Dasanami. The followers of Ramanuja, an 11th-century theologian, are high-caste Hindus but not necessarily of the Brahmin caste. They emphasize ritual worship of a personal deity, and it is possible for the monks to marry. Other orders do not discriminate on the basis of caste.
Jainism. The founders of Jainism gave instruction only to those who were, or intended to become, monks. Founded in the 6th century BC, the religion split into two sects, the Svetambara and the Digambara, around the 6th century AD. Monks and nuns of the Svetambara wear simple white robes and a piece of white cloth to cover the mouth. The cloth prevents the accidental inhaling of microbes or insects. When they are out in public they carry brooms and sweep the ground in front of them as they walk to clear away insects and other living things that would be hurt or killed if they were stepped on.
Both of these unusual practices stem from the Jaina doctrine of ahimsa, or reverence for life. The Digambara traditionally went around naked until Muslim law forced them to adopt a white robe in the 15th century. The Digambara do not accept women into their order. Monks of both orders are mendicants, and they stress poverty and detachment from the world.
Buddhism. Over the centuries Buddhism has split into several schools and sects. Monastic practice, therefore, varies widely throughout the Far East. While celibacy has been a normal requirement of the Buddhist clergy (all of whom are monks), many of the clergy in pre-20th century Ceylon (now Sri Lanka) and Japan married. While meditation is fundamental for all Buddhist monks, many are also heavily involved in society as teachers. Some have been politically active as well. During the Indochina wars, many Buddhist monks protested government policy in South Vietnam.
Sikhism. The order within Sikhism that approximates Hindu standards of monasticism is called the Udasis. The order originated with the followers of Sri Chand, son of the founder of Sikhism. The Udasis require asceticism and celibacy of their members. The other Sikh order, the Khalsa, is not strictly monastic. It was founded as a military brotherhood late in the 17th century, when Sikhs were being persecuted by Muslims. Now the dominant Sikh order, it admits both men and women. Initiates agree to wear uncut hair (and beards for men), a comb, short trousers, a steel bracelet, and a double-edge dagger. They also avoid tobacco and liquor.
Of the three major world religions, only Christianity developed a strong and enduring monastic tradition. Modern Judaism has no monastic orders, though the devotional efforts of some Orthodox rabbis bear striking similarities to the austere lives of some monks. There were semimonastic communities in ancient Judaism around the 1st centuryBC, but these were always marginal to the main emphasis of Temple worship in Jerusalem. Eventually the communities ceased to exist.
Islam. Neither Muhammad, the founder of Islam, nor the Koran, its scriptures, gave any encouragement to monastic ideals. Orders of mystics, called Sufis, did nevertheless emerge in non-Arabic Islam. The Naqshbandiyah, for example, was founded in Turkestan in the 14th century. Today the fraternity can be found in India, China, the Central Asian republics, and Malaysia. The order was always nonconformist, but it influenced the devotional life of Islam during the 18th and 19th centuries. Use of drugs such as hashish, coupled with its antilegalist views, gave the order some appeal at the popular level.
Another group of mystics, the Sanusiyah, was founded in 1837. In modern history the head of this order was the king of Libya from 1951 until 1969, when the country became a socialist state. The Sanusiyah has been a reformist brotherhood, trying to take Islam back to the simple faith and life of earlier centuries. Members of the order also worked as missionaries among the Bedouins of North Africa.
Christianity. The Rule of St. Benedict dominated monastic life in Western, or Roman Catholic, Europe during the Middle Ages. The influence of Benedictine monasticism became evident in the conversion of the barbarians, the development of agriculture, the cultivation of learning, and the teaching of crafts. Among the crafts in which monks worked were painting, wood carving, metalwork, carpentry, weaving, winemaking, tailoring, leather tanning, and clockmaking. English Benedictines were the greatest clockmakers of the 14th century.
Nearly all the great orders of the Middle Ages were founded on the Benedictine plan. The most notable of these were the Carthusians, so called from the monastery of the Grande Chartreuse near Grenoble, France. The order was founded by St. Bruno in 1084. The Cistercians, or White Monks, were founded by St. Robert of Molesmes in 1098. The Premonstratensians, or White Canons, were founded by St. Norbert in 1120. They were named after Premontre, France.
The monasteries established by these orders were all self-contained communities and were divided into abbeys and priories, with the abbey church as the main feature. Around the church were the other buildings, which formed the monastic compound. The monastery's cloister was an enclosed space surrounding all four sides of a rectangular court known as the garth. The four walls of the cloister were roofed. Within it the monks worked at such appointed duties as the copying of manuscripts.
Another building, the refectory, or dining hall, was located at some distance from the church. Near it was a kitchen. The dormitory was normally located near the cloister. Near the dormitory was located an infirmary for the care of the sick and aged. In a nearby garden, or herbarium, herbs used in making medicines were cultivated. In addition to these buildings there were other structures set apart for various kinds of work. Monasteries usually had carpenter shops, book binderies, forges, mills, bakeries, and barns. A guesthouse was a necessary part of every establishment as well, and near the gate there was invariably a shelter for travelers.
All members of a monastery were under the authority of an abbott (from the ancient Aramaic abba, meaning "father"). He was assisted by a prior and a sub-prior. There were several officials known as obedientaries: a lead singer, chief librarian, bursar, and individuals in charge of the kitchen, bakery, infirmary, and other operations. The novice-master was in charge of those studying to become monks or nuns.
In Eastern Orthodox Christianity monasticism took a different course. It remained essentially a movement devoted to meditation and prayer. There was no development of separate orders pursuing special missionary or educational goals. These tasks were often undertaken, however, by individual monks. Russia and other Slavic lands to the north of the Byzantine Empire were colonized and Christianized by monks who acted as pioneers of civilization and as missionaries.